Skip to content

24/7 dementia helpline 800-272-3900

Dementia Today

Dementia: historical overview

Dementia TodayPublished June 20, 20115 min read

Key points

  • All clinical categories, including those pertaining to the dementias, are the result of the coming together in the work of an author of selected behavioural markers, explanatory concepts and terms to refer to them.
  • The crucial issue here is that there is nothing wrong with the fact that social forces shape ‘scientific facts’ and hence contribute to the construction of psychiatric diseases.
  • Knowledge of the history of dementia as a word, a concept and a behavioural syndrome is a precondition for scientific research.
  • GERMAN BERRIOS German Berrios BA (OXFORD), MD, DM H.C.

Since the second edition of this article, no ground-breaking scholarly work has been published that may challenge the historical hypotheses propounded therein on the development of the concept of dementia (Berrios, 2000a); indeed, the ‘constructionist’ view has gained support from the way in which the nosological surface of ‘dementia’ has been redrawn during the last 10 years.

All clinical categories, including those pertaining to the dementias, are the result of the coming together in the work of an author of selected behavioural markers, explanatory concepts and terms to refer to them. Complex social and economic variables will determine whether or not the ensuing ‘convergence’ will last. For reason that have to do with the rhetoric of science, these social acts are sold to the throng as pure ‘scientific acts’. For example, it would be naïve to believe that the decision to consider a symptom-cluster such as, for example,’Lewy body dementia’ as a ‘new disease’ is solely based on the ‘discovery’ of powerful, ineluctable and replicable correlations (Perry et al., 1996). Given that not all correlations are privileged in this way, and that there is no clear theory linking all the symptoms to each other and to the Lewy bodies themselves, it is not difficult to surmise that such consideration is also driven by social variables. The current model of science as a pure pursuit of truth, however, leaves no space for broader explanations and hence all manner of social variables remain understudied.

This is not a new phenomenon, for the same complex mechanisms operated at the time when Kraepelin constructed the concept of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) (Berrios, 1990b).

The crucial issue here is that there is nothing wrong with the fact that social forces shape ‘scientific facts’ and hence contribute to the construction of psychiatric diseases. Indeed, understanding such mechanisms would render psychiatry more complete, the psychiatrist wiser and doctoring more useful to patients.

Hopefully, the time will come when denying social processes may be considered as unethical and offensive to patients.

Knowledge of the history of dementia as a word, a concept and a behavioural syndrome is a precondition for scientific research. Successive historical convergences have shaped the current notion of dementia. A full study should map the changes in the history of ‘dementia’ at least since Roman times.

For the purposes of this section, however, it should suffice to study a shorter period, say, the one stretching from the work of Boissier de Sauvages (1771), who still offered a static view of disease to Marie (1906) whose great treatise would read as very modern to anachronistic eyes. The former defined ‘dementia’ as a generic term; the latter saw in dementia a ‘syndrome’, which could be enacted by a variety of ‘diseases’ each with its recognizable phenomenology and putative neuropathology.

###

Edited by

Alistair Burns MPhil, MD, FRCP, FRCPsych
Professor of Old Age Psychiatry,
Wythenshawe Hospital,
Manchester, UK

John O’Brien MA, DM, FRCPsych
Professor of Old Age Psychiatry,
Institute for Ageing and Health,
University of Newcastle upon Tyne,
Newcastle upon Tyne, UK

David Ames BA, MD, FRCPsych, FRANZCP
Professor of Psychiatry of Old Age,
University of Melbourne, St George’s Hospital, Melbourne,
Victoria, Australia

###

Author:

GERMAN BERRIOS
German Berrios BA (OXFORD), MD, DM H.C. HEIDELBERG, FRCPsych, FBPSS
Professor,
University of Cambridge Department of Psychiatry,
Cambridge, UK

References

  1. Alzheimer A. (1907) Uber eine eigenartige Erkrankung der Hirnrinde.
  2. Allgemeine Zeitschrift fur Psychiatrie und Psychisch-Gerichtlich Medizine 64: 146-148
  3. Alzheimer A. (1911) Uber eigenartige Krankheitsfalle des spateren Alters. Zeitschrift fur die gesamte Neurologie und Psychiatrie 4: 356-385
  4. Anderson EW, Threthowan WH, Kenna JC. (1959) An experimental investigation of simulation and pseudodementia. Acta Psychiatrica et Neurologica Scandinavica 34 (Suppl. 132)
  5. Anonymous (1832) An exposure of the unphilosophical and unchristian expedients adopted by antiphrenologists, for the purpose of obstructing the moral tendencies of phrenology. A review of John Wayte’s book. The Phrenological Journal and Miscellany 7: 615-622
  6. Baillarger J. (1883) Sur la theorie de la paralysie generale. Annales Medico-Psychologiques 35: 18-52; 191-218
  7. Baillarger J. (1889) Doit-on dans la classification des maladies mentales assigner une place a part aux pseudo-paralysies generales? Annales Medico-Psychologiques 41: 521-525
  8. Ball B and Chambard E. (1881) Demence. In: A. Dechambre and L. Lereboullet (eds), Dictionnaire Encyclopedique des Sciences Medicales. Paris, Masson, pp. 559-605
  9. Barrett AM. (1913) Presenile, arteriosclerotic and senile disorders of the brain and cord. In: WA White and SA Jelliffe (eds), The Modern Treatment of Nervous and Mental Diseases. London, Kimpton, pp. 675-709

Full References »

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If a person with dementia is missing, injured or in danger, call 911 or your local emergency number.

Being underweight linked to higher dementia risk
Aging & Dementia

Being underweight linked to higher dementia risk

In the largest study ever to look at relationships between body weight and likelihood of developing dementia, researchers found that being too thin appears to carry the greatest risk. Among nearly two million people in the U.K. observed over time,

4 min read

Worried about memory changes?

Normal aging, or an early warning sign?

Ten common changes, each set beside what is typical with age. Tick what you have noticed and see what to do next.

Open the 10-sign checklist

Getting help

Sudden changes are not just the dementia.

Dementia usually changes slowly. A sharp change over hours or days can mean an infection, delirium, a stroke or a medication problem, and needs a doctor the same day. Call 911 or your local emergency number if you see any of these:

  • Confusion that comes on suddenly, over hours or days
  • Face drooping, arm weakness or slurred speech
  • A fall, a head injury or new severe pain
  • Very drowsy or hard to wake

The free Alzheimer’s Association Helpline answers questions about memory loss, diagnosis and caregiving, day and night, in more than 200 languages (US).

If someone with dementia is missing

  1. STEP 115 minSearch close by firstCheck the house, garden, car and the places the person often walks to. Don’t spend longer than about 15 minutes.
  2. STEP 2911Then call for helpTell the operator the person has dementia and is a vulnerable adult. Police treat this as urgent.
  3. STEP 3PhotoHave details readyA recent photo, what they were wearing, medical conditions and places they used to live or work.

Based on Alzheimer’s Association guidance on wandering. Outside the US, call your local emergency number.