Skip to content

24/7 dementia helpline 800-272-3900

Dementia Today

Mental health courts significantly reduce repeat offenses, jail time

Dementia TodayPublished December 3, 20153 min read
Mental health courts significantly reduce repeat offenses, jail time

Key points

  • New research from North Carolina State University finds that mental health courts are effective at reducing repeat offending, and limiting related jail time, for people with mental health problems – especially those who also have substance use problems.
  • Mental health courts (MHCs) are county-level courts designed to divert offenders with mental health problems from jail, instead referring them to community-based treatment programs.
  • Specifically, the researchers looked at the characteristics of every offender and how each of them fared in the year following their court appearance.
  • “Offenders who went through traditional courts had 1.8 times more charges and spent almost five times more days in jail for repeat offenses, when compared to offenders who graduated from the MHC after completing their terms of participation,” says Evan Lowder, a Ph.D. student at NC State and lead author of the paper.

New research from North Carolina State University finds that mental health courts are effective at reducing repeat offending, and limiting related jail time, for people with mental health problems – especially those who also have substance use problems.

“Previous research has provided mixed data on how effective mental health courts are at reducing recidivism, or repeat offending, for people with mental health problems,” says Sarah Desmarais, an associate professor of psychology at NC State and senior author of a paper on the research. “We wanted to evaluate why or how mental health courts may be effective, and whether there are specific characteristics that tell us which people are most likely to benefit from those courts. The goal here is to find ways to help people and drive down costs for state and local governments without impinging on public safety.”

Mental health courts (MHCs) are county-level courts designed to divert offenders with mental health problems from jail, instead referring them to community-based treatment programs. The goal is to address the underlying mental health problems that contributed to a crime in order to prevent repeat offenses. There are currently more than 300 mental health courts in the United States.

For their study, researchers evaluated 97 people in Minnesota who had mental health problems and had committed misdemeanors or gross misdemeanors, ranging from shoplifting to threatening someone. Fifty-seven of the people went through an MHC, while the other 40 went through the conventional court system.

Specifically, the researchers looked at the characteristics of every offender and how each of them fared in the year following their court appearance.

“The short version is that MHCs work,” Desmarais says.

Offenders that went through normal courts spent 1.6 times more days in jail for repeat offenses than offenders who went through an MHC. And the effect was much stronger when researchers looked at those offenders who went through an MHC and actually completed their MHC treatment programs.

“Offenders who went through traditional courts had 1.8 times more charges and spent almost five times more days in jail for repeat offenses, when compared to offenders who graduated from the MHC after completing their terms of participation,” says Evan Lowder, a Ph.D. student at NC State and lead author of the paper.

The researchers also found that offenders who participated in the MHC who also had substance use problems had a 4.76 times greater decrease in jail time from repeat offending when compared to offenders without substance use problems who participated in the MHC.

“MHCs appear to be especially effective at reducing recidivism for offenders with mental health and co-occurring substance use problems,” Lowder says.

“This tells us that MHCs are effective at reducing repeat offenses, which reduces the burden on law enforcement, the judicial system and – ultimately – the taxpayer,” Desmarais says.

The paper, “Recidivism Following Mental Health Court Exit: Between and Within-Group Comparisons,” was published online Nov. 23 in the journal Law and Human Behavior. The paper was co-authored by Daniel Baucom, an undergraduate at NC State.

###

Matt Shipman
matt_shipman@ncsu.edu
919-515-6386

The content on this site is for information only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If a person with dementia is missing, injured or in danger, call 911 or your local emergency number.

Worried about memory changes?

Normal aging, or an early warning sign?

Ten common changes, each set beside what is typical with age. Tick what you have noticed and see what to do next.

Open the 10-sign checklist

Getting help

Sudden changes are not just the dementia.

Dementia usually changes slowly. A sharp change over hours or days can mean an infection, delirium, a stroke or a medication problem, and needs a doctor the same day. Call 911 or your local emergency number if you see any of these:

  • Confusion that comes on suddenly, over hours or days
  • Face drooping, arm weakness or slurred speech
  • A fall, a head injury or new severe pain
  • Very drowsy or hard to wake

The free Alzheimer’s Association Helpline answers questions about memory loss, diagnosis and caregiving, day and night, in more than 200 languages (US).

If someone with dementia is missing

  1. STEP 115 minSearch close by firstCheck the house, garden, car and the places the person often walks to. Don’t spend longer than about 15 minutes.
  2. STEP 2911Then call for helpTell the operator the person has dementia and is a vulnerable adult. Police treat this as urgent.
  3. STEP 3PhotoHave details readyA recent photo, what they were wearing, medical conditions and places they used to live or work.

Based on Alzheimer’s Association guidance on wandering. Outside the US, call your local emergency number.